Welcome to Cataro's Italian Villa
Cataro's Italian Villa, nestled in Milwaukee, offers an inviting escape into Italian cuisine. This unclaimed gem takes pride in its homemade dishes, particularly the thin-crust pizzas loaded with fresh toppings and a delicious cheese pull that captivates every bite. Guests rave about the creamy lasagna and seasoned garlic bread that melts in the mouth. Despite being a small, family-owned establishment, the welcoming atmosphere and attentive service create a memorable dining experience. With options for takeout and outdoor seating, Cataro's is perfect for dinner with family or groups. Embrace the flavors of Italy just around the corner!
Cataro's Italian Villa: Reviews & Ratings
The lasagna is very good the garlic bread nelts in the mouth the thin crust pizza is great
Best pizza in town! Just a little locally owned place serving phenomenal pizza. Be patient, it's a small place with a small crew, but the food is delicious!
I was looking for a place for dinner saw the pizza looked amazing and decided to give it a chance. God was I right. Garlic bread was SEASONED!! For $4 I was very happy. Then she also brought out our drinks. Small pitcher for $2. Took me the whole time to finish it. Pizza was amazing, it had such a good cheese pull. Also a deep dish for $14. Service was amazing. I don't know her name I'm going to guess she's the owner. It seems family owned and I love the vibe. they do only take cash or LOCAL checks but still amazing
One of the best pizzas I've ever eaten, the pizzas are loaded with toppings, they don't skimp like most places, the Italian dishes are very good as well, very reasonably priced.
I have lived in west allis for around 8 years and I have never tried this once. That was the biggest disservice I could commit. I finally try it and boom new favorite pizza spot. We got a pan pizza, mozzarella sticks, and two orders of garlic bread and our total was $30. Anywhere else including Pizza Hut would be over $40. The quality was fresh and very high. The cheese had an amazingly fresh pull, the pepperoni had great and subtle flavor. The mozzarella sticks were my daughters favorite and got mad when they were gone until she realized she ate them all. We will be back... tomorrow.... Seriously. KEEP IN MIND THEY ARE CASH/CHECK ONLY!!!
I grew up about 3 miles from here. My wife and I drove by this place about once a month and always say we're going to try it. We finally tried it abs it was amazing. Super small dining room and parking lot. We started with an order of outstanding garlic bread and had a 14" thin crust sausage and pepperoni with half onions and half fresh mushrooms. The pizza was fantastic. Super thin crust that was crisp even on the center pieces. The flavor was also great with a touch of heat in the sausage. Great job!!
Location
-
5641 W Beloit Rd Milwaukee, WI 53214 Hotline: (414) 545-1520
Welcome to Cataro's Italian Villa, a hidden gem nestled in Milwaukee at 5641 W Beloit Rd. This charming eatery is unclaimed yet unapologetically devoted to delivering an authentic Italian dining experience that leaves a lasting impression on all who visit.
At Cataro's, the ambiance is casual and inviting, perfect for families and groups looking to enjoy a hearty meal together. With options for outdoor seating and a private parking lot, it's a convenient stop for anyone craving delicious Italian fare. The restaurant embraces a friendly, home-like environment, evident from the moment you step inside. Be sure to take note of their dedication to quality with a focus on exceptional service — many customers rave about the personal touch provided by the staff, which is often viewed as a family effort.
Indulge in their mouthwatering pizzas, which have garnered a faithful following. According to Scott F., the thin crust pizza is nothing short of fantastic, while Kayla W. proclaims it to be the best in town. The generous toppings and fresh ingredients truly shine, offering an unforgettable cheese pull experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. Remember, patience pays off here; it's a small operation working hard to serve outstanding food.
- Lasagna: A crowd favorite, known for its rich flavor and delightful garlic bread.
- Garlic Bread: Described as a melt-in-your-mouth experience that complements any dish perfectly.
- Deep Dish Pizza: An impressive offering at just $14, celebrated for its robust taste and satisfying portion size.
- Affordability: Many customers, like Jake K., have noted how Cataro's manages to serve high-quality meals at prices that won't break the bank.
This family-owned establishment remains committed to an exceptional dining experience, whether you're dining in or taking your favorites home. Please note that Cataro's Italian Villa operates on a cash or local check basis, enhancing its quaint, local charm. Dive into a dish here, and you'll quickly understand why it’s rapidly becoming a beloved cornerstone of the community. For reservations or inquiries, feel free to reach them at (414) 545-1520.
If you're seeking an authentic Italian pizza experience, look no further than Cataro's Italian Villa. The combination of quality ingredients, attentive service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere is sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting more. Stop by today and discover your new favorite pizza spot!
